You (2018) #
— Season 5
The last and final season of the series.
I’m sure Penn has mixed feelings about this. I think he has long been flummoxed by fan support of Joe. “No, he is the villain! He is a terrible person!” Allegedly he almost declined the role in the first place because he didn’t want to glorify stalking and, you know, murder.
Bronte’s turn was awesome. I think it was telegraphed a little bit, but it was still done really well and I liked it.
Six episodes in currently, and I don’t think we’re done yet with Maddie and Rae. I expect there to be another twist with them at some point.
Uncertain so far whether Joe will kill Katie (and maybe Teddy?)
Also curious about the ending for Joe. Killed? Life in prison? Escapes to the Caribbean with Robin Lord Taylor?
Okay, second half of the season: episodes 7 - 10.
7 - 9 keep up the pace and the tension and the suspense. It’s a little over the top as Joe Goldberg is kind of a global phenomenon at this point, and there’s more than a couple killers on the cast now.
Joe is calm and controlled in the first four seasons. This season he is prone to fits and outbursts as he hurdles forward toward the conclusion. I think we are meant to see the bestial side of him, the vampire Ezra from his writing. Him losing his son’s affection is kind of hamfisted in delivery, but no less heartbreaking.
Anna Camp as Maddie and Reagan Lockwood is the breakout star of the season. She is at turns believably vile, hilarious, and tragic.
Madeline Brewer as Bronte / Louise is fine. She’s kind of nervous and weird with a tinge of terror, which is what you want from the character.
Episode 10, the finale, is disappointing and a shift in tone and content from the rest of the season. It’s like the writers hand-wave a bunch of stuff so that they can tee up a genre shift (survival horror slasher flick) and a final confrontation (final girl in the cabin in the woods). I would have let Kate and Joe both die in the fire, and let Bronte have chosen for it to happen. That’s nice and tidy and satisfying. Instead Bronte is shot, drowned, throws herself from a second story window, and then shoots Joe in the dick. Ridiculous.
The final scene is Joe in a box (prison) which is satisfying. And the final lines are certainly just a self-insert for Penn as he looks at the camera and addresses the viewers, “the problem is you.” But here’s the thing. Penn would be right if he was addressing people idolizing and fawning over some kind of actual serial killer. But Joe Goldberg is a fictional character who is designed to be engrossing enough to sell seasons of television. He is captivating by design. Yes he is a villain. But also, yes we love to watch him.
It was fine!
This show is a consistently good thriller. Season 1 is possibly must-see television, and it possibly peaks at Season 4. You can honestly skip season 5. 5/5 stars!